Authors: Tracey C. Shi; David Pagliaccio; Marilyn Cyr; H. Blair Simpson; Rachel Marsh · Research
Can Brain Connectivity Patterns Predict How Well OCD Patients Respond to Therapy?
This study examined brain connectivity in OCD patients and found patterns that may help predict response to exposure therapy.
Source: Shi, T. C., Pagliaccio, D., Cyr, M., Simpson, H. B., & Marsh, R. (2021). Network-based functional connectivity predicts response to exposure therapy in unmedicated adults with obsessive–compulsive disorder. Neuropsychopharmacology, 46(6), 1035-1044. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41386-020-00929-9
What you need to know
- This study examined brain connectivity patterns in unmedicated adults with OCD compared to healthy controls.
- OCD patients showed altered connectivity between regions involved in attention, cognitive control, and default mode processing.
- Certain connectivity patterns predicted how well patients responded to exposure therapy for OCD.
- The findings suggest altered communication between brain regions may contribute to OCD symptoms and treatment response.
Understanding OCD and Brain Networks
Obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) is a mental health condition characterized by intrusive, unwanted thoughts (obsessions) and repetitive behaviors or mental acts (compulsions) that a person feels compelled to perform. While we know OCD involves dysfunction in certain brain circuits, the exact neural mechanisms are still not fully understood.
Previous research has identified abnormalities in connections between different regions of the brain in people with OCD. However, studies have varied in their specific findings, possibly due to differences in methods and whether participants were taking medication. This study aimed to examine brain connectivity patterns in unmedicated OCD patients and explore how these patterns might predict response to a type of therapy called exposure and response prevention (ERP).
Examining Brain Connectivity
The researchers used a brain imaging technique called resting-state functional MRI to examine connectivity between different brain regions in 41 unmedicated adults with OCD and 36 healthy control participants. This technique measures how the activity of different brain areas is coordinated when a person is at rest and not performing any specific task.
They focused on examining connectivity across the whole brain, rather than just looking at specific regions of interest. This allowed them to potentially uncover new patterns of altered connectivity in OCD that may have been missed by more targeted approaches.
Key Findings on Brain Connectivity in OCD
The study found that OCD patients showed altered connectivity in a network of brain regions, primarily centered around areas in the temporal lobes of the brain. Specifically:
There was reduced connectivity between regions in the middle and superior temporal gyri and areas involved in attention, cognitive control, and task-positive processing. Task-positive regions are those that tend to be more active when a person is engaged in goal-directed tasks.
At the same time, there was increased connectivity between some temporal lobe regions and areas involved in self-referential thinking and mind-wandering (part of the default mode network).
These findings suggest an imbalance in OCD between brain networks involved in external attention/cognitive control and those involved in internal mental processes. This altered connectivity pattern may contribute to the difficulty OCD patients have in controlling intrusive thoughts and resisting compulsive behaviors.
Predicting Response to Therapy
After the brain scans, the OCD patients underwent 8 weeks of twice-weekly exposure and response prevention therapy. This is a type of cognitive-behavioral therapy that involves gradually exposing a person to situations that trigger their obsessions while helping them resist performing compulsions.
The researchers found that the degree of altered connectivity in certain brain networks at the start of treatment predicted how well patients responded to the therapy. Specifically, patients who showed more reduced connectivity between temporal lobe regions and areas involved in cognitive control tended to have a greater reduction in OCD symptoms with treatment.
This suggests that patterns of brain connectivity may be useful biomarkers for predicting which patients are most likely to benefit from exposure therapy. However, the researchers caution that these findings need to be replicated in larger studies before they could be applied clinically.
Implications and Future Directions
This study provides new insights into the brain connectivity patterns associated with OCD and how they may relate to treatment response. The findings highlight the importance of communication between brain networks involved in attention, cognitive control, and internal mental processes in OCD.
Some key implications and future directions from this work include:
The need to look beyond just the classic brain circuits associated with OCD to understand the disorder. Whole-brain approaches may reveal new patterns of dysfunction.
The potential for brain connectivity measures to eventually help guide treatment selection for OCD patients. However, more research is needed before this could be applied clinically.
The importance of studying unmedicated patients, as medications can affect brain activity patterns.
The need for larger studies to replicate and extend these findings, including examining how brain connectivity patterns may change with successful treatment.
Conclusions
- Unmedicated OCD patients show altered connectivity between brain regions involved in attention, cognitive control, and internal mental processes.
- These connectivity patterns may contribute to the symptoms of OCD and predict response to exposure therapy.
- Examining whole-brain connectivity, rather than just specific circuits, can reveal new insights into the neurobiology of OCD.
- While promising, more research is needed before brain connectivity measures could be used clinically to guide OCD treatment.